Skip to main content
Faculty Research

Know Thy Employees: How to Lead in an Age of Hidden Trauma

A sudden drop in performance isn’t always a motivation problem. Trauma-informed leaders know what to look for and which practices best support employee healing.

In 2023, BYU Marriott Professor Lisa Jones Christensen was invited to speak at The Summit, an annual BYU conference aimed at motivating and inspiring students. With free rein to select her own topic, she chose to do what professors usually do: talk about their research.

Illustration of man and woman at water cooler and man looks drained.

After wrapping up her remarks, Jones Christensen expected a few short follow-up conversations. Instead, she stood wide-eyed as a seemingly endless line of students waited to talk with her.

“So many people said they needed to hear what I had shared,” Jones Christensen recalls. “Some were weeping; others were smiling. Many asked how they could learn more. It was a testament that when people feel seen, they want to share. It was a turning point for me.”

Her keynote focused on an unexpected topic for a motivational speech: trauma. Not necessarily “big-T trauma,” such as surviving war as a refugee or losing parents at a young age, but also the quieter forms of trauma that come from experiences such as moving overseas as a child and not having friends or growing up in a home impacted by mental illness. Jones Christensen’s presentation explored how leaders can support those who have faced trauma in any form, without needing to act as a therapist or know personal details.

The students’ overwhelming reaction to Jones Christensen’s message on trauma and trauma-informed leadership underscores why business leaders should take note. According to a 2023 study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, nearly two-thirds of adults in the United States have experienced trauma through adverse childhood experiences,1 which can affect job performance in misunderstood ways. In professional environments, the strain can manifest as silence, turnover, poor decision-making, or compulsive overworking—costs that organizations are already paying for.

Defining Trauma-Informed Leadership

At its core, trauma-informed leadership is about helping employees thrive. The idea is simple: Give leaders a toolkit to support and manage employees whose performance is being hindered by a sudden intrusion of difficult past experiences or by stress responses that bring out old patterns tied to those experiences.

“When capable people go quiet, get rigid, or stop contributing at prior levels, most leaders think it’s a motivation problem or a culture problem,” says Jones Christensen, the Lorin Farr Associate Professor of Management. “It’s actually a capacity problem, and capacity can be restored.”

Under pressure, people impacted by trauma can lose access to clear thinking, confidence, and innovation—not because they lack drive but because their nervous system gets overloaded. Jones Christensen explains that the prefrontal cortex—where judgment, creativity, and individuality operate—goes offline when it believes it’s under threat.

“Leaders who understand this stop misreading their employees,” she explains. “Instead of adding more intensity and threat, they protect the capacities that people need to perform.”

To help, Jones Christensen has developed a framework that translates the science and psychology around trauma-informed leadership in noncorporate settings into concrete leadership strategies for corporate settings. The approach, called the SAFER framework, centers on five practices: Safety, Awareness, Flexibility, Empathy, and Regulation and Repair. Built and tested across veteran, refugee, and emergency-care settings, these practices translate directly into boardrooms, startups, and high-growth organizations.

“Many clinics and schools have changed outcomes massively by applying trauma-informed principles,” says Jones Christensen. “There is even a government manual that defines trauma-informed care. But those ideas have been slower to reach the business world.”

A Personal Journey

A two-time breast cancer survivor, Jones Christensen experienced a disease that traumatized every part of her life—her health, her marriage, her family, and her career. But it was her background in international development, working specifically with refugees, that sparked an interest in studying trauma.

Years ago, Jones Christensen was supporting refugee entrepreneurs at a farmer’s market in Salt Lake City when a nearby car backfired loudly. The refugee vendor she was talking with immediately dove under the table, leaving a pile of unguarded merchandise and money.

“In that instant, there was nothing more important to her than taking cover,” Jones Christensen recalls. “It occurred to me how people are often left to their own devices to deal with PTSD while they’re trying to manage their lives and make a living.”

Over the course of the next year, Jones Christensen published a few academic articles on trauma with Beth Embry, an assistant professor of management at the University of Kansas. She also collaborated with fellow BYU Marriott professor Paul Godfrey. The enthusiastic response to the research convinced Jones Christensen that she needed to do more.

In the years that followed, she went all in to better understand trauma, earning six different certifications in the area and pitching a book idea to Routledge/Taylor & Francis. The book, titled The Trauma-Informed Leader: What to Do to Keep Your Best People from Going Silent, is set to be published in January 2027.

About the Word Trauma

As her research developed, Jones Christensen consulted with scholars and experts, including former BYU Marriott mental health specialist Aliah Hall. The two met while Hall was leading workshops with faculty on what trauma looks like and how it affects students. Sometimes Hall got pushback on the topic because people viewed the term as referring only to severe, life-altering events.

But Hall believes there are two buckets: trauma that threatens how you live your life (“big-T trauma”) and trauma that makes you feel out of control (“small-t trauma”). Both are valid and have real impact. When those “small-t trauma” stressors stack to the point that someone feels out of control, the impact on the nervous system can mirror the symptoms of “big-T trauma,” Hall says.

“There are so many things happening in our community and world that we carry, which cause us to function a little differently,” continues Hall, who now works in the counseling center at BYU–Hawaii. “We can’t pack that all up and put it in our pocket when we go to work; it comes with us.”

Illustration of rope that is frayed and about to break but fray looks like hands reaching for each other.

Jones Christensen says the compounding nature of those stressors matters. After years of pandemic, economic instability, and geopolitical upheaval, many people are operating under sustained stress and have a permanently elevated baseline. The nervous system has not recovered from the last disruption before the next one arrives. As a result, Jones Christensen says that trauma-informed leadership “has become urgent. It offers tools that work when others stop working.”

While older generations may not want to talk about trauma or may believe it’s something to be worked out solely with a therapist, Jones Christensen says that the generation now entering the workforce does want to talk about it.

“I’m not going to shy away from the word trauma; I am going to be an ambassador for the word,” Jones Christensen adds. “I used to think that only the things I’ve seen in third-world countries—assault, starvation, displacement—or what war veterans face qualify as trauma. But scholars have helped me learn that trauma is not what happens to you, it is what happens inside of you.”

A Framework That Works

Jones Christensen’s research shows that businesses implementing trauma-informed care can see powerful gains in cost savings, job satisfaction, well-being, trust, retention, and service quality, with the most statistically significant impacts on healthcare costs, stress reduction, burnout, and absenteeism.

The core concept of the SAFER framework is to provide solutions that don’t require managers to adopt a new style of leadership, become therapists, or diagnose their employees. And employees don’t need to disclose any personal information. In practice, the approach is more about what managers design, how they speak, and when they should intervene. Here is a look at the five principles at the heart of the framework paired with sample scripts that show how to put each principle into practice.

Safety: Design workplace conditions that are physically and psychologically safe enough that people can think and speak under pressure.

When it comes to addressing safety in a trauma-informed fashion, it’s not only about the physical safety of doors, locks, and lighting. Jones Christensen and Embry believe it is about whether people can predict what will happen next. Leaders need to send consistent signals that the environment is safe. In practice, that can be as straightforward as publishing clear agendas before every meeting, summarizing decisions before they are made, or explaining what will happen after a difficult conversation.

When it comes to meetings—especially those with high stakes—there are several easy-to-implement practices that significantly help employees. Beyond sharing the agenda in advance, managers can start and end on time, briefly review the agenda at the outset, and state time constraints early on. (“We have 15 minutes to discuss the risks.”) Another simple practice is to offer employees choices. (“Sit where you’re most comfortable.” “Cameras are optional.” “Step out at any point if you need to.”)

Here are some additional scripts provided by Jones Christensen that can increase the sense of psychological safety in the workplace:

“You do not need to be certain to raise a concern; your perspective matters.”

  • “If you raise a concern, you won’t be penalized for it.”
  • “I’ll follow up in writing on our final decision so our decision today and our future actions match.”
  • The safety element of the framework is about bringing predictability to the work environment. “Individuals rarely know when, where, and why they will react to different triggers,” says Embry, who worked as a public health practitioner before transitioning to academia. “Predictability reduces the impact to the nervous system.”

Awareness: Intervene early to curb tension before it hardens into conflict, address fatigue before it becomes burnout, and deal with silence before it becomes misconduct or apathy.

Researchers are adamant that true awareness hinges on early detection. In other words, leaders who practice awareness watch for the signals that precede performance drops: the high performer who stops asking questions in group settings, the team member whose updates get shorter, or the meeting where everyone agrees immediately and no one pushes back. When these situations arise, leaders might try the following scripts:

  • “I think I missed something earlier. Let’s back up one step.”
  • “I stopped reading the room. Give me 30 seconds to catch up.”

One often-overlooked aspect of awareness is recognizing how seemingly harmless workplace traditions can affect employees. Off-site holiday parties held in the evening or on the weekend are one example. “When attendance is at an unfamiliar location, the issues of physical safety and psychological safety come to the forefront,” says Jones Christensen. “When it is socially unacceptable to not attend, then choice is gone. One person’s type of celebration meant to motivate, thank, or inspire could be another person’s source of anxiety—or an unexpected financial burden or expense.”

Just being aware that something planned to celebrate can have the opposite impact is a meaningful first step. According to Jones Christensen, slight adjustments can make all the difference: Instead of the off-site weekend holiday party, try a voluntary event during workday hours on-site or at a familiar location. For those who can’t be there or who aren’t comfortable attending, send them an Uber Eats gift card.

Another surprising insight from the research: Calling a workplace a “family” doesn’t always create belonging. For employees who grew up with abuse, addiction, neglect, or other unhealthy dynamics, the word family can carry painful associations. In cases like this, Jones Christensen says, “referring to the team as ‘family’ can be problematic or even triggering.”

Flexibility: Adapt roles, processes, and responses as conditions change—but don’t abandon standards or accountability.

Flexibility failures occur when leaders themselves go rigid under pressure and resort to measures such as narrowing decision rights, adding approval layers, or shortening meetings to avoid debate. While leaders gain a sense of control from these behaviors, employees often experience them as threats. Teams under rigid leadership act compliant but stop flagging problems or sharing new ideas.

Illustration showing small man at table with laptop sitting in middle of Zen garden with large hand next to him combing the sand around him.

The kind of flexibility Jones Christensen describes has less to do with workplace perks than with how organizations handle pressure. Flexibility allows organizations to experience stress without driving more fear. Jones Christensen calls this “codified flexibility,” where flexibility is baked into leadership rather than improvised on the fly. For example, leaders practicing trauma-informed flexibility keep strategic priorities stable while deciding in advance who can make which decisions, when timelines can flex, and when remote work is an option.

“Flexibility is not lack of standards; it is not drift,” Embry says. “It is disciplined adaptability under pressure.”

It’s also critical that flexibility has built-in limitations. When every decision is open to interpretation, employees can become overwhelmed by choice, leading to decision fatigue and burnout. Instead of spending cognitive energy on logistics (“When do we meet?”), managers can focus on purpose (“Why are we meeting?”). Here are two relevant scripts:

  • “You don’t need permission to decide within your boundary. If the risk is under X, go ahead and act and then brief us on what you learned.”
  • “I’m not taking this decision away from you.”

Empathy: Recognize signals of risk in individuals while ensuring that operational decisions do not inadvertently retraumatize or destabilize.

Picture a senior leader delivering necessary feedback to a high performer during a quarterly review. Within minutes, the employee becomes defensive, quiet, and distant. The leader may see a resilience problem and increase pressure, when in reality, the employee’s nervous system has registered a threat and narrowed cognitive access. Feedback meant to be developmental was processed as risk.

Empathy focuses on recognizing what is happening biologically and responding to the underlying situation instead of the surface behavior. “A leader who can properly show empathy delivers the same standards with dramatically different outcomes,” says Jones Christensen. You can put empathy into action with these scripts:

  • “Let’s pause for a moment so we can stay clear and constructive.”
  • “I’m noticing some intensity here. Slowing down will help us think better.”
  • “I can understand why this felt discouraging, even if the decision stands.”
  • “Your reaction makes sense given the circumstances.”

Regulation and Repair: Stay steady, notice strain early, and repair rupture so individuals can rebuild trust and recover performance more quickly.

Leaders can approach hard conversations carefully and offer employees some choice about when and where those conversations happen. Beyond responding in the moment, leaders who practice regulation will check back to support employees and connect them with needed resources.

When follow-up is required after hard conversations, it should happen within 48 hours. Research shows that silence after a difficult conversation can cause an employee and a supervisor to become further entrenched on opposite sides. A 2022 Gallup study found that the most significant predictor of employee disengagement is a manager who ignores problems.2 In contrast, a leader who “repairs” issues with a trauma-informed mentality owns their part of the conflict first and focuses on the impact to the employee:

  • “I recognized that my reaction caused harm. I want to understand the impact before we move to solutions.”
  • “Something feels off after that meeting. Let’s repair that instead of ignoring it.”
  • “I appreciate you raising that concern. It takes courage and helps us build the culture we want.”

For Jones Christensen, repair represents a value central to BYU Marriott’s mission. “Ultimately, this approach is personal because it provides ways to be Christlike in business while not lowering your standards. It holds people accountable with kindness,”
she says.

Adds Hall: “Part of our covenant responsibility is that when we see someone struggling, we don’t look away.”

The Impact

When implemented consistently, the SAFER framework helps restore the sense of agency that trauma often takes away. Simple practices or scripts allow leaders to support employees while maintaining professional standards.

“The way trauma manifests itself is not always predictable,” Embry explains. “When you are deep in your amygdala—in that fight-or-flight survival mode—you cannot fully access your frontal cortex. That limits your ability to think critically, make decisions, respond promptly, and communicate effectively.”

But simple actions can go a long way. Preparing agendas, allowing seating choice, and providing clear policies might seem small, but they have an enormous positive impact on someone’s central nervous system, notes Jones Christensen.

“Trauma-informed practices for leadership translate into overall best practices for leading,” Jones Christensen says. “Trauma-informed leadership is not only about supporting individuals who are dealing with trauma or other mental health issues but supporting the entire team. It makes for a great working environment.”

______

Todd Hollingshead is the national news director for BYU’s University Communications office. He’s been writing feature pieces for Marriott Alumni Magazine since 2009.

Illustrations by Jon Krause.

______

Notes

  1. Elizabeth A. Swedo et al., “Prevalence of Adverse Childhood Experiences Among U.S. Adults—Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, 2011–2020,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 72 (June 30, 2023):707–715, dx.doi.org/10.15585/mmwr.mm7226a2.
  2. Jim Harter, “Disengagement Persists Among U.S. Employees,” Gallup, April 24, 2022 (updated September 11, 2023), gallup.com/workplace/391922/employee-engagement-slump-continues.aspx.